Okutepa SAN Urges NBA to Balance Lawyer Discipline with Judicial Accountability

Senior Advocate of Nigeria, Jibrin Okutepa, SAN, has called on the Nigerian Bar Association to ensure fairness and consistency in the enforcement of professional ethics, warning against the use of disciplinary proceedings to discourage legitimate criticism of judicial decisions.

In a statement published on his X account on November 17, 2026, the senior advocate addressed the controversy surrounding disciplinary proceedings reportedly initiated against a legal practitioner over comments made about a judicial officer.

The development followed the NBA’s decision to petition the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee (LPDC) over alleged insulting remarks made by lawyer Kalu Kalu during a television programme.

Okutepa acknowledged the NBA’s authority to initiate disciplinary complaints against lawyers accused of professional misconduct. He, however, maintained that professional discipline must be administered in a manner that preserves fairness and protects the integrity of the legal profession.

He drew a distinction between personal attacks against judicial officers and legitimate criticism of judicial decisions, arguing that lawyers must be able to question judicial reasoning, identify legal errors and speak against perceived injustice without resorting to abusive language.

According to him, disagreement with a judgment does not justify insulting the judge who delivered it.

The SAN also raised questions about the consistency of professional disciplinary measures, particularly where allegations concern conduct by lawyers involved in politics or persons who may have made statements suggesting improper influence over judicial decisions.

He questioned whether such conduct should equally attract the attention of the NBA’s disciplinary mechanisms.

On judicial accountability, Okutepa maintained that judges were bound by their constitutional and professional obligations to uphold independence, impartiality and integrity.

He cautioned that judicial decisions should not give reasonable grounds for the perception that justice had been influenced by political loyalty, personal interests or external pressure.

He nevertheless acknowledged that an unpopular judgment was not necessarily an unjust judgment, noting that judicial decisions must ultimately be assessed on the law, evidence and reasoning supporting them.

The senior advocate further extended his concerns to the internal administration of the NBA, arguing that an association seeking to enforce ethical standards must demonstrate those same standards in its leadership selection, disciplinary processes and institutional affairs.

He maintained that calls for unity and institutional dignity should not be used to avoid accountability where credible concerns have been raised.

Okutepa urged the NBA to uphold judicial independence while preserving the right of legal practitioners to raise legitimate concerns about the administration of justice.

His intervention has brought renewed attention to the relationship between professional discipline, freedom of legal expression, judicial accountability and the responsibility of the Bar to maintain public confidence in the justice system.

READ MORE:

NBA Faces Fresh Call to Resolve LPDC Appeal Gap

Olanipekun Urges Action Over LPDC Appeal Gap

author avatar
LegalLinkz
SPONSORED
Lawyers in Business Institute seal
Lawyers in Business InstituteSince 2019 · RC 135532
Lawyers’ Mass-Housing& Land-Banking Scheme
TrainingsCar swap & flipTreasury bills & money marketMortgagePensionArmed escortAnd more
Office: Suite A8, Kenuj O2 Mall,
behind Games Village, Abuja
5A, CGH, Games Village, Abuja

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

SPONSORED Advertisement